More than 1 in 4 parents in a new survey admitted to exaggerating or inventing their child’s symptoms to get antibiotics, and almost all of them say it worked. The findings, published in JAMA Network Open, land at the start of cold-and-flu season, exactly when pediatric offices are packed with coughing kids and worried parents hoping for a quick fix.
Here’s what the research found, why so many parents feel pushed to stretch the truth, and how to get your sick child the right care without risking the side effects of medicine they don’t need.
Antibiotics for Kids: What the JAMA Study Found
The research letter, “Caregiver Symptom Misrepresentation to Obtain Antibiotics in Pediatric Encounters,” was published online Oct. 30, 2026. The lead author is Alistair Thorpe, PhD, of the University of Utah’s Spencer Fox Eccles School of Medicine, and the team surveyed U.S. adults online between Jan. 8 and Feb. 13, 2026. Within that survey, 236 parents, stepparents or guardians of children under 18 answered questions about their child’s care (JAMA Network Open).
- 26.7% (63 caregivers) said they had misrepresented their child’s symptoms to get antibiotics
- 24.2% had exaggerated symptoms the child really had
- 23.6% had made up symptoms entirely
- 19.1% had done both
And the strategy usually succeeded. Among caregivers who misrepresented symptoms, about 87% said they walked away with antibiotics at least once, and 38% said it worked more than once.
A Companion Study in Adults
The same research group also studied adults seeking antibiotics for themselves. According to Live Science, about 28% of nearly 960 adults said they had misrepresented symptoms, most often cold-like complaints such as fever, cough and sore throat. “As clinicians, we know that patients lie to us sometimes,” Dr. Jeffrey Linder, who wrote an accompanying commentary, told the outlet.
Why Parents Stretch the Truth
The study’s most revealing data is about motives, and they are very human. Among parents who misrepresented symptoms:
- 71.4% said the child felt really sick
- 71.4% thought antibiotics were the only thing that would help
- 66.7% wanted to get back to their responsibilities more quickly
- 63.5% said they know their child’s body and history better than a clinician
- 60.3% were worried about a serious infection
- 57.1% had a friend or family member recommend exaggerating or making up symptoms
Trust was a recurring theme. Nearly two-thirds (63.5%) of the parents who misrepresented symptoms said they often felt clinicians don’t take their symptoms seriously, compared with 31.2% of parents who never did. The researchers wrote that this suggests misrepresentation “may reflect issues in the caregiver-clinician relationship and misconceptions about antibiotics.”
Important Limits
The sample was relatively small and came from a national nonprobability online panel, which means it may not perfectly represent all U.S. parents. The authors also cautioned that their regression estimates were exploratory and “should be interpreted with caution.” Still, the pattern matches what many pediatricians report anecdotally.
Why Antibiotics for Kids Can Backfire
It’s easy to think an extra prescription is harmless. It isn’t. According to the CDC:
- Antibiotics do not work on viruses, which cause colds, flu, most sore throats (except strep) and most chest colds (bronchitis).
- Many sinus infections and some ear infections clear up without antibiotics.
- In children, side effects from antibiotics are the most common cause of medication-related emergency department visits.
There’s a community cost too. Every unnecessary course gives bacteria another chance to develop resistance. The CDC’s latest Antimicrobial Resistance Threats Report estimates that the drug-resistant bacteria and fungi it tracks cause 9.7 million infections and 50,800 deaths in the U.S. each year.
Viral vs. Bacterial: A Quick Parent Cheat Sheet
| Illness | Usually caused by | Antibiotics helpful? |
|---|---|---|
| Common cold, runny nose | Virus | No |
| Flu | Virus | No (antivirals may be an option) |
| Most sore throats | Virus | No |
| Strep throat | Bacteria | Yes, after a positive test |
| Whooping cough | Bacteria | Yes |
| Urinary tract infection | Bacteria | Yes |
| Some ear and sinus infections | Virus or bacteria | Sometimes; often watchful waiting first |
Based on CDC guidance. Your child’s clinician makes the final call.
How to Get Your Sick Child the Right Care (Without Fibbing)
If you’ve ever felt dismissed at the pediatrician’s office, these steps can help you be heard honestly:
- Track symptoms on your phone. Note temperatures with times, how long the cough has lasted, and changes in eating, drinking and sleeping. Specific facts are more persuasive than exaggeration.
- Say what worries you most. “I’m scared this is pneumonia because she’s breathing fast” gives the clinician something concrete to examine.
- Ask “What else can help?” Comfort care such as fluids, rest, fever reducers when appropriate, and humidified air often matters most for viral illness.
- Ask when to come back. A clear plan, such as “return if the fever lasts more than X days,” turns a “no antibiotics” visit into a safety net.
- Ask about tests. A rapid strep test or a urine test can settle the question with data instead of guesswork.
- Know the red flags. Trouble breathing, signs of dehydration, unusual drowsiness, or a fever in a very young infant need prompt medical attention.
Staying ahead of seasonal illness helps too. Our age-by-age guide to flu, COVID and RSV vaccines for kids covers what’s recommended this season.
The takeaway: Parents who stretch the truth are usually acting out of love and exhaustion, not carelessness. But when it comes to antibiotics for kids, honest details get better care, and the right answer is sometimes rest, fluids and a follow-up plan instead of a prescription.
This article is for general information only and is not medical advice. Contact your child’s healthcare provider with any concerns.